New York City’s dining scene is an ever-evolving spectacle, with rooftop restaurants continuing to redefine the city’s culinary landscape. Among the latest and most talked-about additions is elNico, a rooftop sanctuary perched atop Penny Williamsburg, bringing an innovative twist to contemporary Mexican cuisine. With a menu curated by Michelin-starred Chef Fer Serrano and a cocktail program that turns heads as much as the sweeping Manhattan views, elNico has quickly cemented itself as a must-visit destination in Brooklyn.
A Sky-High Culinary Oasis in Williamsburg
Located at the intersection of industrial charm and modern sophistication, elNico is more than just a rooftop eatery—it’s an immersive experience. As you step onto the terrace, you’re instantly greeted by a breathtaking panorama of the Manhattan skyline. The vibrant yet refined decor, accentuated by lush greenery, warm ambient lighting, and stylish seating arrangements, evokes a sense of relaxed luxury. Whether you’re here for an intimate date night, a celebratory dinner, or a casual sunset cocktail, elNico’s atmosphere is designed to elevate the occasion.
The Menu: A Bold Reinvention of Mexican Classics
At the heart of elNico’s appeal is its menu, a testament to Chef Fer Serrano’s visionary approach to Mexican cuisine. The dishes are deeply rooted in tradition yet reimagined with innovative techniques and high-quality, seasonal ingredients. Every plate at elNico tells a story, balancing authenticity with modern sophistication.
Small Plates with Big Flavors
The Tostada de Atún is a refreshing and vibrant start—delicately sliced tuna, marinated in a citrus-forward sauce, sits atop a crispy tostada with avocado purée and pickled onions, delivering a perfect balance of crunch and freshness. Another standout is the Esquites, a playful yet elevated take on Mexican street corn, featuring charred corn kernels with aioli, lime, and a dusting of chili for a smoky, tangy kick.
Entrées That Command Attention
Among the entrées, the Mole Negro Short Rib steals the show. Slow-cooked to perfection, the short rib is tender, richly flavored, and enveloped in a velvety Oaxacan mole negro sauce that offers a complex interplay of deep, earthy, and slightly sweet notes. The dish is beautifully complemented by house-made tortillas, allowing diners to savor every last drop.
For a lighter yet equally indulgent option, the Grilled Branzino is a must-try. Served with a citrus-forward salsa and a side of roasted seasonal vegetables, the dish highlights elNico’s commitment to fresh, high-quality ingredients.
Decadent Desserts
Ending on a high note, the Tres Leches Cake is a textural masterpiece—moist, creamy, and infused with a hint of vanilla, topped with fresh berries and a delicate caramel drizzle. Meanwhile, the Churros with Spiced Chocolate Sauce bring the perfect level of crunch and sweetness, ensuring a comforting yet sophisticated finish to the meal.
Cocktail Program: A Spirited Affair
No rooftop dining experience is complete without a stellar cocktail selection, and elNico delivers in spades. The beverage program is as daring and refined as the menu, featuring cocktails that marry bold flavors with impeccable craftsmanship.
The Nico Margarita is an instant favorite—smooth, citrusy, and perfectly balanced with a hint of smoky mezcal for depth. Another standout is the Flor de Jamaica Spritz, a floral and slightly tart refresher that plays beautifully with the summer breeze. For those looking for an adventurous sip, the Ancho Negroni offers a spicy, bittersweet twist on the classic, infused with ancho chili liqueur for a slow-building warmth.
Service and Ambience: The Art of Hospitality
From the moment you arrive, elNico’s service is impeccable. The staff is knowledgeable, attentive, and genuinely passionate about the food and drinks they serve. Whether offering pairing recommendations or providing insights into the inspirations behind each dish, their enthusiasm adds an extra layer of warmth to the experience.
The ambiance shifts seamlessly throughout the day—lively and sun-soaked in the afternoons, intimate and enchanting as the city lights begin to twinkle in the evening. The music is thoughtfully curated, creating an atmosphere that enhances but never overpowers the dining experience.
Final Verdict: A New Brooklyn Icon
elNico is not just another trendy rooftop restaurant—it’s a culinary destination that masterfully blends tradition with innovation. From the expertly crafted menu to the mesmerizing skyline backdrop, every element is carefully considered to create a truly memorable dining experience. Whether you’re a Brooklyn local or a visitor eager to explore the borough’s evolving food scene, elNico is a must-visit spot that delivers on every front.
Pro Tips for Visiting elNico
- Reservations are highly recommended, especially for sunset dining when the rooftop ambiance is at its peak.
- Dress stylishly but comfortably—the setting is upscale yet inviting.
- Opt for a tasting approach by sharing multiple small plates and entrées to experience the breadth of flavors.
- Don’t skip the cocktails—elNico’s mixology program is as much a highlight as the food.
Brooklyn’s culinary skyline has a new shining star, and its name is elNico. Whether you’re here for the exceptional cuisine, the craft cocktails, or simply the view, this rooftop haven delivers an experience that lingers long after the last bite. For more info on elNico….
For more restaurant reviews, insider dining guides, and all things NYC, stay tuned to Minted NYC.
